Innovation versus the Sputnik fallacy
Published in The Tennessean , Sunday, January 30, 2011 Innovation versus the Sputnik fallacy by Richard J. Grant In Lake Wobegon, are all the subsidies above average? Does everyone receive more in payments from the government than they pay in taxes? Lake Wobegon's above-average students would recognize immediately that it is impossible to receive such across-the-board subsidies from Lake Wobegon's government alone. The extra resources would necessarily come from outsiders, perhaps from a neighboring county. No doubt President Barack Obama had visions of America as one big Lake Wobegon when he warned us that, “This is our generation's Sputnik moment.” He fears that we might be falling behind in scientific research, noting that China has become “the home to the world's largest solar research facility and the world's fastest computer.” His solution is to subsidize innovation, whatever he imagines that to be. It is of course quite likely, if we send more research dollar...