Social Security is based on poor business model
Published in The Tennessean , February 28, 2010 Social Security is based on poor business model by Richard J. Grant Suppose you decide that you need a vacation, and the price of that vacation just happens to be $5,000. But you don't have enough cash, so you borrow the $5,000 from your retirement account and place an IOU for that amount in your account. Now you can go enjoy your vacation and pay yourself back later – perhaps with interest. What is the effect of this action? Instead of $5,000 in cash assets, you now have a $5,000 IOU from yourself, as well as a $5,000 liability to yourself. Instead of a $5,000 net-asset position, you have happy vacation memories. Also, you might be pleased that you do not owe the money to a bank: you "owe it to yourself." If you are happy with this outcome, that is fine. But what does it mean for your future? If the IOU is still in your account when you retire, what is it worth? Let's pretend you could sell it for $5,000. But you would